Educated Exercises: 21 Discussion Questions

Tara Westover grew up in the mountains of Idaho, in a family that distrusted schools, doctors, and the government. She did not sit in a classroom until she was 17. Later she earned a PhD from Cambridge. Her memoir asks what an education costs and who you become when you get one.

This book stirs up strong feelings, so these questions work best for a group that trusts each other. They also work as private journal prompts.

Educated Exercises

Educated is a memoir about family, loyalty, and self invention. Westover writes about the pull of the people who raised her and the pull of a bigger world. She also writes about how memory works and how hard it is to trust your own version of events when others tell it differently.

We put together seven exercises with 21 discussion questions. Some ask you to think about hard family topics, so go at your own pace.

Exercise 1. The world you were born into

Westover's early life shaped what she believed was normal.

1. What did you assume was normal as a child that you later learned was not?
2. Which beliefs from your family do you still hold, and which have you questioned?
3. How did Westover's father shape what she believed about the world? Where do you see that influence in her choices?

Exercise 2. What education means

For Westover, school opened a door she did not know existed.

1. What was the first idea you learned that changed how you saw things?
2. Why do you think Westover felt so lost in her first classes at university? What did she have to learn beyond the material?
3. Do you think education always frees a person? Explain your view.

Exercise 3. Loyalty and honesty

The book keeps returning to a painful question. What do you owe the people who raised you?

1. Where does Westover face a choice between loyalty and truth? What would you have done?
2. Have you ever kept quiet to keep the peace at home? What did it cost you?
3. Can you love your family and still disagree with them? What does that look like in practice?

Exercise 4. Memory and the story you tell

Westover uses footnotes to show where her memory and her family's memory do not match.

1. Think of a family event that different people remember differently. Why might that happen?
2. How does Westover handle the gaps between her account and others?
3. How much should you trust your own memory when the people around you disagree?

Exercise 5. Fear and obedience

Fear runs through the household Westover describes. Some decisions were made out of belief, and some were made out of fear.

1. How can you tell the difference between real belief and fear of consequences?
2. Which moments show Westover starting to trust her own judgment?
3. When did you first trust your own judgment over someone you were expected to obey?

Exercise 6. Mentors and outside voices

Teachers and friends helped Westover see her own potential.

1. Who believed in you before you believed in yourself?
2. What did that person do that made the difference?
3. How can you be that person for someone else?

Exercise 7. The cost of change

Westover pays a high price for her education. She gains a new life, and she loses part of her old one.

1. What did Westover gain, and what did she lose?
2. Have you ever changed in a way that made it hard to go home? How did you handle it?
3. By the end of the book, who do you think Westover has become? What does she say about the self she has built?

Ideas worth remembering

Westover grew up as the youngest of seven children on a mountain in Idaho. Her father distrusted public schools and hospitals, and she spent much of her childhood working in his scrapyard. She taught herself enough to take the ACT and entered Brigham Young University at 17. She later studied at Cambridge and earned a PhD in history there.

She published the memoir in 2018 and says she changed some names to protect people. She also uses footnotes to flag where her memory differs from what family members recall, which is why memory is a theme in this discussion guide.

Where readers get stuck

The book describes violence in Westover's home, and some readers find those chapters heavy. That is a normal reaction. You can skip questions that feel too close to your own life, and you can return to them later or never.

Readers also disagree about her family. Some see her parents as sincere people shaped by their beliefs, and others see harm. Good discussion leaves room for both reactions without forcing a verdict.

How to use these questions

This works well as a book club guide. Read the memoir first, then choose two or three exercises per meeting rather than all seven. Give people time to think before anyone speaks.

Set a simple ground rule at the start. People share only what they want to share, and nobody has to explain their family. That keeps the room safe for honest answers.

If you are using the questions alone, treat them as journal prompts. Write for ten minutes on one question, then stop. You can always come back tomorrow for the next one.

Putting it into practice

After you finish the questions, write one page about the moment you first saw your own life differently. It might be a class, a book, a job, or a conversation. Say what changed and what it cost you.

If you belong to a book club, pair Educated with a short talk about the people who helped you learn. Ask each member to bring one teacher, mentor, or friend they want to thank.

Then reach out to that person. A short note that says what they did and how it helped can mean more than you think.

Read the full summary

Want a quick refresher on the story before your next discussion? Read the Educated summary on Sumizeit and see how Westover tells it.

Ready for more books like this? Upgrade your plan to unlock every book on Sumizeit.